Wednesday, January 19, 2022
Home / cjar  / Archives  / AP High Court judge’s appointment comes under SC scanner

AP High Court judge’s appointment comes under SC scanner


The Supreme Court today agreed to scrutinise the appointment of an Andhra Pradesh High Court judge, Justice N V Ramana, despite pendency of a criminal case against him during his appointment, and sought from the Attorney General all documents pertaining to his elevation.


A bench of justices Aftab Alam and Ranjana Desai also expressed surprise that he was appointed on the advice of erstwhile Union Law Minister Ram Jethmalani, who, appearing as an advocate for the petitioner, was now seeking quashing of his elevation.

“Mr Jethmalani you have an illustrious career spreading over several decades. You had held number of posts and conducted several cases about which you are also not aware. In this case the collegium had twice rejected the name of this particular judge but it was at the instance of the then law minister that the appointment was made”, the bench said. When the bench pointed it out to Jethmalani, he said if some wrong has been done, it can be undone too.


“Your lordships are trying to say that I was the law minister at that time. Your lordship can suggest me what can be done to undo it”, Jethmalani replied.